German or Russian Arties?

Posted: Fri Oct 10, 2008 8:02 pm

Which do you prefer?
The German Arty Tank Regiment
30% Higher Morale with Advanced Armor Training
Respectable light tank units
Best Command Tank unit
Schurzen upgrade

Hummel Arty Tank Unit
25% Faster Attack Speed with Improved Fire Control

The Russian Arty Tank Regiment
Best light tank units with highest health and defense value
Second best Command Tank unit

ISU-152 Arty Tank Unit
+6 range with Long Range Artillery
Best health and defense value

Major General (MG) Joined: Sept 29, 2005 Posts: 1384

I'll take German, i swear this game has a "Russian Glitch"...where no matter what you do you cant kill shit...not every game, but i swear ive had plenty of games like this.

Posted: Sat Oct 11, 2008 1:14 pm

ill go with the germans. especially with the upgrades they make them superior. but the us artys have great range

Posted: Thu Oct 16, 2008 2:10 pm

i chose russian, cuase i swear to god 1 V bomb could kill ur arty germ tanks

it happened to me, and i did it to someone else(in one game)

Staff Sergeant (SSG) Joined: Sep 21, 2007 Posts: 115

i think russian arts mutch mutch mutch better i never have any sucess wit german arts... but i have seen people have a lot more success with going a mix of arts and kings.

P.S i need ts ip got a new comp noone gave it to me yet !!!!!!

Posted: Thu Oct 16, 2008 5:21 pm

bullshit , bullshit , bullshit german craftmanship is far superior to rinky dinky russian assembly line crap

Posted: Fri Oct 17, 2008 7:57 am

yup, but 1 V and ur dead

Posted: Fri Oct 17, 2008 5:54 pm

I love the German tanks because they have alot of upgradres for their tanks, however, German Arties dont have long range upgrade. The porpuse of Artillery is bombing the enemy from a long distance and just for that reason I have to take Russian Arties over German Arties. Russian Arties have long range, Gyros, Diesel engines and mech reliabilty, on the other hand German Arties get affected by too many upgrades like Schurzen, Gyros, Improved fire control, Advanced Armored Training, Logistics and Diesel Motors. If German Arties had long Range upgrade they would be the best Artillery tanks in the game. Lets say if Russian Arties fight German Arties in the trees the German Arties have no chance because they lack Long Range while Russians Arties doesn't. But is they are fighting in a map like Africa or india then Germans Arties have a good chance because there arent a loty of tress and German Arties at a short rane are really good. Anyways, my vote goes for Russian Arties.

Posted: Fri Oct 17, 2008 9:26 pm

yes but German arties have improved fire control , whereas Russians do not... that means 5 bombards to the opponents 4.... Germans have better morale... but how often you see an arty tank routing? I have to ask myself is the arty tank regiment one of the most balanced in A&A?

they are all distinctly different, yet all have something they do well at. Even the Brits, who have weak command and support units, have all the good upgrades.....

if you were gonna rank them i might say:

1 USA
2 GER
3 RUS
4 GBR
5 JPN

With arties, maybe it comes down to the micro of the individual player more than the diff between regiments?

BTW: It is a myth that Japan Arties (and arty mech, they worst in game) do more morale damage than others... that is only for Japan mortars...

Posted: Sat Oct 18, 2008 5:56 am

guys i like german arty but never use alone.
alweys suport them with tank or mech thats is mor efectiv that only arty.

Posted: Sat Oct 18, 2008 2:51 pm

i think your all wrong, german arty should be used exactly like mech, they are great at engaugement.

Posted: Sun Oct 19, 2008 3:50 pm

i agree with spas, jap arty are said to own, but they dont unless they have banzai then they can fight a bit

Posted: Mon Oct 20, 2008 8:19 am

golani i dont sey that i use german arty like bombard mode . but sometimes is good to use in first line only mech in second arty and when retret mech just start fight with arty like mech ( its like taktical reserv).